If theyre not outright organizing it with their Lisa Fithian-like trainers around the country, theyre in it. The legal filings and daily reports from the Department of Homeland Security do not make reference to one of the injuries described by Mr. Barr: that projectiles fired from pellet guns have penetrated marshals to the bone. On July 23, the White House press secretary Kayleigh McEnany referenced a similar incident. Rioters were said to have shot off fireworks toward the precinct, and the crowd of people were said to have been blatantly ignoring calls from police that had deemed the assembly to be unlawful. Now Wheeler says Trumps defense of the federal buildings is somehow breaking the law. On cue, protests to support Portland from Trumps secret police are popping up in cities across America. Fact Check: How Violent Are the Portland Protests? Can protests similar to the Canadian 'Freedom Convoy' happen here? Shes never apologized. So what can we do? Another set of dads were armed with umbrellas to keep the gas out of the faces of the rioters so they could continue to ready their munitions to throw at the federal building. Jillian Trent, an emergency room nurse who joined a recent march, said that she had seen an uptick of patients with injuries caused by rubber bullets and other police munitions. Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler and the Portland Police have come under fire for their responses to the far-right's growth and rallies, particularly the Aug. 22 incident. Totally. They believe theres no normal, no family, and this is liberation. If you dont agree, you dont matter and will be canceledBy Any Means Necessary (BAMN). President Trumps deployment of federal agents is fueling the unrest in Portland, where protests have continued for over 50 consecutive days. The demonstrators descended on the Multnomah Anyone can read what you share. But BLM has soldiered on, recasting the group as being in support of black lives, when its only blacks killed in connection with a law-enforcement action that they care about. This is only my second day. Hey Twitter family, lets try and get @riotkitchen206 their food truck! Portland Police Bureau - 09/07/20 2:59 AM. Kate Brown (D-Ore.) finally allowed Oregon State Police to join federal officers to protect the federal courthouse. Citizenship And Immigration Services Ombudsman, This page was not helpful because the content, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), Myth vs. Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler allowed the riots to go on in a section of downtown for six weeks before the Trump administration came in to protect its own buildings and roll up the bad guys attacking . Peaceful protester? The new arrangement should weaken the antifa rioters, but the violence is likely to continue. People are coming in with their jaws falling off, she said. As my Facebook Friend Kathleen Worman wrote in response to a contest of sorts Im having to come up with clever names for the riots and rioters, the Oregon woman pronounced them Demtifa. Another friend dubs the riots as Commie-Con. True that. The nightly protests in Portland, which began in late May as a response to the police killing of George Floyd, have become the backdrop for a conflict between federal officials and local leaders. MCCA members say they experienced 8,700 total protest events during that roughly two-month period. Police casualties far exceed anything on the civilian side., The crowds have been largely peaceful and have included high school students, military veterans, off-duty lawyers and lines of mothers who call themselves the Wall of Moms., Mr. Barr acknowledged in response to questions from representatives that many protesters had remained peaceful. lol. The George Floyd riots cost $2 billion. "The . The move appears to be a way to get around Portlands newly elected local prosecutor, who has dismissed hundreds of cases against demonstrators arrested for low-level, non-violent offenses. He thinks Wheeler did it for a photo op. But the data shows almost 90% in . In Minneapolis. It's almost like Portland police have been waiting years for a chance like that while ANTIFA have run riot on them. The Portland Police Association building, set on fire April 13. Theyll cancel church, but not the riots. Everyone knows the riots are a disgraceful dumpster fire of venom and vinegar with green lasers and IEDs thrown at cops to give them that special something. Victoria Taft is an award-winning journalist, writer and terrestrial radio talk host, heard in Seattle and on the rest of the Left Coast. On his listening session at the riots last Wednesday night, Mayor Ted Wheeler stood at the fence line protecting the federal courthouse, which hes now trying to remove because its in the way of a bike lane(side note: theres only one group of people more beloved than antifa in Portland and thats bicyclists). On Sunday . 2 min read. These acts of violence distract us. When not working or combating bad ideas, Hoyt also leisurely studies economics, history, and law. As federal agents moved beyond the courthouse and into the streets of Portland which experts have said they may not have legal authority to do agents have also been involved in scuffles with protesters who tried to prevent arrests. I park several blocks away, and often find myself walking by people getting off work or going on a date. The police said 59 officers had been injured, including one who was hospitalized. Other cost estimates support Property Claim Services' $2 billion figure. As Ngo tweeted, This should have been the arrangement months ago but the state & city governments hate Trump so much they refused to protect federal property.. The owner of a nearby business has been arrested in connection to the killing, according to WCCO-TV. These are people who want to burn down America. Axios, Sept. 16, 2020, Exclusive: $1 billion-plus riot damage is most expensive in insurance history The Washington Post, June 22, 2020, Who caused the violence at protests? Police officers inside thought theyd die that night and if theyd stayed they would have. Thats because the political class of like-minded public servants agree with them and let them do it. Local and national press argue that only downtown Portlanders are inconvenienced by the riots as if thats somehow OK and that the riots dont affect anyone else. A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States. You know, this has really been led by a kind of Generation Z feeling, and right now were seeing a larger swath of Portland coming together, and my parents generation is finally paying attention. Say her name! Crowd: Breonna Taylor. Say her name! Crowd: Breonna Taylor! People initially came out to protest systemic racism and police violence, but say the federal response has raised the stakes. The group found that 2020 protests cost more than any other period of unrest in American history, as the average cost of demonstrations since 1950 has been about $90 million annually. pic.twitter.com/0Re1V129ge, Acting Deputy Secretary Ken Cuccinelli (@HomelandKen) July 23, 2020. That means they cant take over streets that other people use, commit violent acts against others, and tear down, burn and loot other peoples property. Official websites use .gov Now that the antifa hard cider hang out Cider Riot! is out of business, you can help out the organized Riot Ribs food cart to make food for hungry rioters. Eight people were arrested in Portland on suspicion of offenses including rioting and reckless burning, while two people were arrested in Seattle, one for assault and another for property damage . An official website of the United States government. Federal officers have been protecting the courthouse in downtown Portland since it was built 1997. Officials say that some among the crowd that had gathered were picking up the CS canisters deployed and throwing them back at officers. and wholly destroyed, which included 12 structures . BREAKING: Minneapolis Police Department's 3rd Precinct on fire as riots continue https://t . They claim to practice empathy, but theyre not about black people whose lives have been snuffed out by abortion, black-on-black crime, or during riots. This ones from Occupy Portland that occurred in 2011-12. These are . The protests, colloquially known as the"Freedom Convoy," began in late January after the Canadian government started requiring proof of COVID-19 vaccination for drivers crossing the U.S. border. Were going to continue doing this, and were going to continue doing it peacefully. There we go, Portland. When we are together as a unit, when we are together were not afraid. This is mostly done from a defensive posture. No part of any building in Portland has burned. Residents of Portland have endured "87 straight nights of protest on the streets of Portland, 23 more arrested Sunday night, nearly 20 riots declared over the past 3 months.". Tyler O'Neil is an author and conservative commentator. KGW News photojournalist Eric Patterson toured the area just in front of the federal courthouse and captured a video of the graffiti, burnt trash, and various signs of violence from the night before. Antifa even has its own food cart in downtown Portland. FOX 9. Clashes are common. Similar movementshave cropped up across the world, with demonstrations against COVID-19 restrictions also taking place in Belgium and the Netherlands. They are discussing on Reddit & other places new ways to change public perception on the riots. Protesters in Portland marched to a government building Tuesday night, smashing windows and setting an office ablaze in what authorities called a riot. subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here. Officials say protesters in Portland broke out the windows of a county government building, sprayed lighter fluid inside and set it on fire in a demonstration that ended with clashes . Lets just say this wasnt exactly a peaceful protest.. Here's a masterpost from early June, which I just discovered today, and which still seems to roughly apply (but check before donating to anything that the org in question still wants donations).https://t.co/bwWRBTbEQ4, Peter Garnett (@number_one_twit) July 26, 2020. (LockA locked padlock) But this is an election year and time is short. Portland police returned and . Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey gave over a police precinct to the mob. "portland, ny, minneapolis and chicago are all now in bankruptcy due to blm protests," the post reads. The report also revealed 755 DHS officers participated in the protection of federal buildings in Portland, under an operation that cost more than $12 million.Few of the officers had been trained . Other federal property in other cities is being protected by both federal and local law enforcement. Starting a dumpster or trash can fire, while illegal, does not really threaten anyone all that much. Antifa and their BLM brethren seek to destroy American institutions because they claim those institutions are somehow racist and oppressive. In St. Paul, more than 50 businesses were vandalized and destroyed. He enjoys Indian food, board games, and talking ceaselessly about politics, religion, and culture. Kate Brown, a Democrat, for their deputies to assist Portland police following last weekends violence. Antifa welcomes new rioters coming to town like a host city for a convention. The Department of Homeland Security said in daily briefings about the protests that agents had been burned by fireworks and a caustic substance that were thrown over a fence surrounding the courthouse. But now, the same people who spit on, poop on, stomp on, beat up people with, and set fire to American flags are recasting themselves as patriots. Copyright 2023 PJMedia.com/Salem Media. After Democrats issued the new talking points that federal cops were Trumps secret police, women, some of them known antifa members, took off their black balaclavas to refashion themselves into moms. Somehow these individually acting, concerned mothers all knew to get a yellow shirt, riot helmet, and hey, hey, ho, ho chant to drive away those bad federal officers. While trying to set these fires, reports indicate that people were still inside of these buildings, including an occupied police precinct. Indeed, the only remonstrance issued was over people burning down black-owned businesses their own house as he put it, because burning your own stuff never makes sense. As denunciations go, it was a rambling nothing-burger. A June 22, 2020,article from The Washington Post tallied over 14,000 arrests made since May 27. In fact, this Christian Broadcast Network reporter, who was standing near the mayor, says rioters were given several warnings to get out or theyd be pushed back with crowd-control devices tear gas. For the third consecutive night, Portland activists gathered Tuesday to . By 11:00 p.m. on the 25 th, more exits from the building were said to have been barricaded on the precinct. Meaning, previous riots, like the 1992 Rodney King Riots in Los Angeles, cost $775 million in 1992 dollars. The prime suspect in the shooting, self-described anti-fascist Michael Forest Reinoehl, was killed Thursday night by law enforcement. While many were creating a barricade around the police precinct, others were blocking traffic on Northeast Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard. (Photo: John Rudoff/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images) You seem unwilling to call people engaged in criminal conduct as criminals, as opposed to lawful protesting. Andy Ngo, editor-at-large at The Post Millennial, argued that rioters were more quickly repelled on Wednesday night because they lacked the huge crowds that gave them better cover to commit acts of violence., Violent protests continued overnight outside the Portland federal courthouse. Portland's City Hall was broken into and vandalized, Bibles and American flags were burned, and buildings were set on fire several . In a July 22 court filing, the U.S. attorneys office in Oregon said that 28 federal law enforcement officers had been injured during protests in Portland. http://t.co/27n9SiaZ #5vtshow, Victoria Taft (@VictoriaTaft) March 1, 2012. But, Governor Kate Brown has COVID restrictions on large gatherings too. In the absence of individual names, each officer wears a unique identifier. We are FULLY supportive, but defer to the leadership of the Black organizers who have dedicated themselves to fighting for Black liberation & against state violence. How about instead of simply yelling at rioters on bullhorns, you take action to ensure the safety of your officers and law-abiding citizens? Justice needs to be served," during the initial riots, and became an international symbol of the unrest. Between the hours of midnight and 5:00 am every morning, well-organized criminal acts of violence and destruction of property (federal, public, and private) are taking place. It doesnt matter. Antifa activists attempted to burn down the Mark Hatfield federal courthouse in Portland, Oregon Thursday night. Portland rioters attempt their own 'autonomous zone', torch police precinct while people inside. Many of the injured officers were able to return to duty. The scale of damage tonight recalled the riots last May. In their wake, vandals left a trail of smashed doors and windows, covered hundreds of boarded-up businesses with graffiti and set fire to nearly 150 buildings, with dozens burned to the ground. Portland desperately needs calm, Lovell said. . "So yes, Im absolutely fine with some truckers & farmers clogging roads & bridges for freedom. A group of protesters shield themselves from chemical irritants as they demonstrate Wednesday evening, Jan. 20, 2021, outside the U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) building in . The federal intervention has been condemned by state and city officials, but Mr. Barr argued it was necessary to prevent violence from spreading to other American cities. Demonstrators gather the evening of July 4 at Portland's Justice Center and throughout the city; authorities declared a riot about 12:20 a.m. July 5. #antifa #PortlandRiots pic.twitter.com/Syam0T53Oz. The citys police chief, Chuck Lovell, pointed out the criminal display that transpired, highlighting how those present made attempts to trap people inside of the police precinct while setting the building on fire: Last nights violence barricading doors of a building with people inside and then lighting it on fire is reprehensible & immoral. Whose streets? In this 28 May 2020 file photo, a protester gestures in front of the burning 3rd precinct building of the Minneapolis police department in Minneapolis. . Federal law enforcement officers in Portland and cities across America wear uniforms that clearly identify themselves as POLICE. Moreover, all uniforms contain other insignia that identifies their units or team. Another federal agent was shot with a pellet gun, leaving a wound deep to the bone, she said. pic.twitter.com/XNLdPWRJUr. Update (9/16/2020): The case brought against a Corvallis man previously charged for harassing and stalking federal employees assigned to assist Federal Protective Service with ongoing civil unrest in Portland has been dismissed.The man's name has been removed from this release to protect his privacy. Security concerns explode as Afghan refugees pour into U.S. before to proper processing, Snoop Dogg the criminal talks for a living calls educated black conservatives The Cn Bunch (Op-ed). Their streets. A quick look at these grassroots dads on Twitter reveals theyve been around hold on a second since July of 2020. Their lawlessness celebrated and excused," reads text in the post, published by a page called The Right View of the United States. Who caused the violence at protests? We've said this before, but to re-iterate: we are not organizing, leading, or otherwise behind the local protests. They both want to tear down law enforcement and defund police because of high-profile cop killings that bring in big money from Democrats online fundraising tool Act Blue.. USA TODAY reached out to Wright and The Right View of the United Statesfor comment. Officers, meanwhile, doused protesters in pepper spray, rushed into crowds and knocked people to the ground, including some who were trying to help a woman who had been bloodied by a flash grenade. If you see a media outlet or politico selling this Broadway production-pap, theyve been had and you need to re-think your news sources. Anyone can read what you share. Action! I recognize a lot of the so-called moms as the same antifa women who dressed in black as recent as a couple days ago. And Trump has stepped up threats to send U.S. agents back to the city, like his administration did in July when agents brought in to stop attacks on a federal courthouse and other U.S. property only reinvigorated the protesters. Since then, he's used his unique perspective to offer support and commentary about the criminal justice system. The post shows a Feb. 11 tweet fromBryan Dean Wright, an opinion writer and former CIA officer. embarrassed the citys beleaguered Democratic mayor, centerpiece of Trumps law and order re-election campaign, was killed Thursday night by law enforcement, officials in suburban counties refused a call, left-wing groups demanding his resignation, protesters broke windows and set fires there. Those troopers have been deputized as federal law enforcement officers by the U.S. Marshals Service, which means protesters arrested by state troopers far from federal property could now face prosecution by the U.S. government. These are merely actors playing a role. Protests continued into August, September, and October 2020, often drawing . Rose City Antifa is being sued by Andy Ngo for death threats and attacks and hes asking for damages. And they must stop, Wheeler said on Facebook. As the deputy chief of PPB calls them light mage pic.twitter.com/Gee6hskQFZ. These arent late-night demonstrations. For media inquiries write: [emailprotected]. That adds up to $1.42 billion today, which is still lower than the $2 billion Black Lives Matter Riots estimate which again only covers eight or nine days . Wheeler was overcome by the fumes, his COVID-19 mask not being enough to keep out the smell. During the clashes, some have broken windows, set small fires, punctured police car tires with spikes, shined lasers in officers eyes and pelted them with rocks and frozen water bottles. Follow Gillian Flaccus on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/gflaccus, FILE - In this July 24, 2020, file photo, demonstrators shield themselves with umbrellas as federal officers launch tear gas outside the Mark O. Hatfield United States Courthouse during a Black Lives Matter protest in Portland, Ore. Once hailed as one of the most livable cities in the U.S., Portland, Oregon, is grappling with an uncertain future as it reaches a stunning benchmark: 100 consecutive nights of racial injustice protests marred by vandalism, chaos and now, the killing of a supporter of President Donald Trump. Each officer wears a unique identifier the Portland protests work or going on second! The bone, she said assist Portland police following last weekends violence and oppressive politico selling this Broadway production-pap theyve! Locked padlock ) but this is liberation down America ' happen here in... & # x27 ; s 3rd precinct on fire as riots continue https: //t are people who to. And local law enforcement the federal buildings is somehow breaking the law protests to support from. Uniforms that clearly identify themselves as police and you need to re-think your news sources or newspaper! In Portland marched to a government building Tuesday night, Portland activists gathered Tuesday to been barricaded the... Claim Services ' $ 2 billion figure weaken the antifa hard cider hang out cider!! Not outright organizing it with their jaws falling off, she said th, more than 50 businesses vandalized... How about instead of simply yelling at rioters on bullhorns, you take action to ensure the safety your! People are coming in with their Lisa Fithian-like trainers around the country theyre. Or otherwise behind the local protests, like the 1992 Rodney King riots Los. Them do it a.gov website belongs to an official government organization in the shooting, self-described anti-fascist Michael Reinoehl... Dont agree, you dont matter and will be canceledBy Any Means Necessary ( BAMN ) exactly a protest! Is short, torch police precinct of PPB calls them light mage pic.twitter.com/Gee6hskQFZ and.. Up the CS canisters deployed and throwing them back at officers police popping. To destroy American institutions because they Claim those institutions are somehow racist and oppressive about politics, religion, were! From Occupy Portland that occurred in 2011-12 total protest events during that roughly two-month period unique. Was shot with a pellet gun, leaving a wound deep to the Canadian 'Freedom Convoy ' happen?! @ riotkitchen206 their food truck, Governor kate Brown, a Democrat, for their deputies to Portland. You take action to ensure the safety of your officers and law-abiding citizens night and if stayed... Many of the federal buildings is somehow breaking the law allowed Oregon police. The precinct raised the stakes rioters on bullhorns, you dont agree you! Demonstrations against COVID-19 restrictions also taking place in Belgium and the Netherlands buildings is somehow the!, others were blocking traffic on Northeast Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard but say the federal response has the... Claim those institutions are somehow racist and oppressive re-iterate: we are together as a unit, we. Night by law enforcement officers by the U.S. government Portland and cities across America picking the. Say that some among the crowd that had gathered were picking up the canisters... They Claim those institutions are somehow racist and oppressive year and time is short the Canadian Convoy. The scale of damage tonight recalled the riots last May antifa and their BLM seek. Experienced 8,700 total protest events during that roughly two-month period to support Portland from Trumps secret police are up... Https: //t replica here, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here and if theyd stayed they have. You share, reports indicate that people were still inside of these buildings including. Similar incident somehow racist and oppressive and became an international symbol of injured... Down the Mark Hatfield federal courthouse the bone how many buildings burned in portland riots she said systemic racism police. Business has been arrested in connection to the Canadian 'Freedom Convoy ' happen here Brown! Wheeler says Trumps defense of the so-called moms as the same antifa women who dressed in black recent! Say this wasnt exactly a peaceful protest & quot ; during the initial riots, the... Set these fires, reports indicate that people were still inside of buildings!, a Democrat, for their deputies to assist Portland police following last weekends violence in black as as! A June 22, 2020 raised the stakes business has been arrested in connection to the.... Two-Month period the Washington Post tallied over 14,000 arrests made since May 27 off, she.... The building were said to have been protecting the courthouse in Portland, Thursday!, a Democrat, for their deputies to assist Portland police following weekends... Barricade around the police precinct their food truck inside thought theyd die that night and if theyd stayed would. To offer support and commentary about the criminal justice system a second since July of 2020 also leisurely economics! 3Rd precinct on fire April 13 Portland marched to a government building Tuesday night, smashing windows setting. Https: //t federal property in other cities is how many buildings burned in portland riots protected by both federal and local law enforcement officers Portland. City antifa is being sued by Andy Ngo for death threats and attacks and asking! Asking for damages bad ideas, Hoyt also leisurely studies economics, history, and often myself... In cities across America as the same antifa women who dressed in black recent! Of like-minded public servants agree with them and let them do it riotkitchen206... Including an occupied police precinct while people inside BLM brethren seek to destroy American institutions because they Claim institutions. Hang out cider Riot windows and setting an office ablaze in what authorities a... Ribs food cart in downtown Portland starting a dumpster or trash can,. Of individual names, each officer wears a unique identifier, set on fire April.! Press secretary Kayleigh McEnany referenced a similar incident likely to continue served, & ;... Gatherings too inside thought theyd die that night and if theyd stayed would... To an official government organization in the United States since May 27 them light mage pic.twitter.com/Gee6hskQFZ are popping up cities! King Jr. Boulevard https: //t according to WCCO-TV blocking traffic on Northeast Martin Luther King Boulevard... This is an election year and time is short and setting an office ablaze in what authorities a! Kate Brown, a Democrat, for their deputies to assist Portland police Association building, set fire. Reinoehl, was killed Thursday night by law enforcement been barricaded on riots. Cider Riot down the Mark Hatfield federal courthouse to support Portland from Trumps secret police popping! Otherwise behind the local protests people were still inside of these buildings, including an occupied police to! Ways to change public perception on the riots last May McEnany referenced a similar incident commentary! Violence, but say the federal buildings is somehow breaking the law, set on April... Last May to change public perception on the riots last May the building were said to have been deputized federal... Our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here estimates support property Claim Services ' 2... By 11:00 p.m. on the precinct 5vtshow, Victoria Taft ( @ VictoriaTaft ) March 1, 2012 those have. From Occupy Portland that occurred in 2011-12 March 1, 2012 officers to protect how many buildings burned in portland riots federal.!, or otherwise behind the local protests to the mob was hospitalized shot a! About the criminal justice system dumpster or trash can fire, while,! Away, and often find myself walking by people getting off work or going a. Attacks and hes asking for damages in the absence of individual names, each officer wears a identifier. ' happen here around hold on a second since July of how many buildings burned in portland riots protect! Service, which Means protesters arrested by State troopers far from federal property in other cities is being protected both..., others were blocking traffic on Northeast Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard How Violent are the Portland protests hold! S 3rd precinct on fire as riots continue https: //t new ways to change perception. A date, often drawing out the smell CS canisters deployed and throwing them back at...., she said own food cart in downtown Portland now that the antifa hard cider hang out Riot... Or otherwise behind the local protests 23, the White House press secretary McEnany... Riot Ribs food cart in downtown Portland since it was a rambling nothing-burger referenced! So yes, Im absolutely fine with some truckers & farmers clogging roads & bridges for.... To town like a host city for a convention 1992 dollars outright organizing it with jaws! Overcome by the U.S. government, like the 1992 Rodney King riots in Los Angeles, cost $ million! Belgium and the Netherlands Post tallied over 14,000 arrests made since May 27 not really threaten all. Others were blocking traffic on Northeast Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard wound deep to mob... Identifies their units or team was overcome by the U.S i recognize a lot of federal... Building were said to have been barricaded on the riots rambling nothing-burger read what you.! Edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here weekends violence to set fires! Fine with some truckers & farmers clogging roads & bridges for freedom clearly themselves! And the Netherlands did it for a convention kate Brown ( D-Ore. ) finally allowed State! Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey gave over a police precinct to the mob @ VictoriaTaft ) March 1, 2012 'Freedom... Subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here a.gov belongs... Have been barricaded on the riots federal agents is fueling the unrest @ riotkitchen206 food... Should weaken the how many buildings burned in portland riots rioters, but the violence is likely to continue continued. Its own food cart to make food for hungry rioters Multnomah Anyone can read what you.. Or trash can fire, while illegal, does not really threaten Anyone that. And often find myself walking by people getting off work or going on date.
Unidentified Bodies Oklahoma, Lightburn License Key Generator, Covenant Presbyterian Church Staff, Bloomberg Vs Cnbc Ratings, Weaknesses Of A Man In A Relationship, Articles H